We are officially closed as of

Saturday, June 25, 2022. We would like to thank all our customers for your years of support.

We wish you all the best!

More Than Just A Bakery

Stop in and check out our Gourmet Dip Mixes, Gourmet Popcorn,

Chocolate Candies, Amish Jams, Candleberry Candles and more!

We are always adding New Bakery Items as well as New Gourmet Products so stop in often.

Because we bake fresh daily, limited quantities are available each day.

Featured Products

(0)

4 Dozen Thumbprint Cookies Shipped to You!

$30.00

In stock

Select Options
(0)

Almond Raspberry Cupcakes (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Amish Jams

Different Prices & Varieties

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Anna Cupcakes (Frozen Movie)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Banana Nut Muffins

2.99 each

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Berry Pineapple Tray Cake

$20.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Black Forest Tray Cake

$20.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Blue Thumbprint Cookies (1 Dozen)

$7.50

In stock

Select Options
(0)

Blueberry Streusel Muffins

2.99 each

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Butterscotch Praline Cookies

$1.25ea or $12.50 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Cake Pops - Christmas Bow (Seasonal)

$30.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Cake Pops - Christmas Ginger Bread (1 Dozen Seasonal)

30.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Cake Pops - Christmas Poinsettia (1 Dozen Seasonal)

$30.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Cake Pops - Cookies and Cream (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cake Pops - Easter Carrots (Seasonal)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cake Pops - Easter Chicks & Bunnies

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cake Pops - Mystical Mermaid

$30.00

Pickup allow 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cake Pops - Red Velvet (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cake Pops - Smores (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cake Pops - Valentine Purple-Pink Rose

$30.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Cake Pops - Wedding Rose

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(1)

Cake Pops-Cotton Candy (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Candleberry Candles

Different Prices & Varieties

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Caramel Apple Streusel Muffins (Seasonal)

2.99 each

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Chai Signature Cake

$45.00

Please allow 3-4 business days for pickup

Select Options
(0)

Cherry Cheesecake Tray Cake

$20.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cherry Chip Cake Pops (1Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$.95ea or $9.50 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Chocolate Eclairs

$2.99ea

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Chocolate Peppermint Crunch Cookies (1 Dozen Seasonal)

$9.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Chocolate Raspberry Turnovers

$2.99

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Chocolate Reese's Cupcakes (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Chocolate Rose (1 Dozen)

$25.00

Pick-up 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Christmas Cupcakes (1 Dozen Seasonal)

$30.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Christmas Thumbprint Cookies (1 Dozen)

$7.50

In stock

Select Options
(0)

Classic Birthday Cake Pops (1 Dozen)

$25.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Classic Cupcakes (1 Dozen)

$20.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cookie Monster Sugar Cookies

$25.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cotton Candy Cake

$45.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Cream Cheese Cherry Danish

$2.99ea

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Crème Horns

$2.89ea

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Daisy Cupcakes

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Disney Princess Cupcake Collection

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Easter Cookie Kits (Seasonal)

$25.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Easter Cupcakes (Seasonal)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Elsa Cupcakes (Frozen Movie)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Emoji Valentine Sugar Cookies (1 Dozen)

$18.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Face Mask Sugar Cookies (1 Dozen)

$25.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Flower Bouquet Cupcakes

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Flower Cupcakes with Pearls

$35.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Gingerbread Man Cookie Kits (Seasonal)

$25.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Gourmet Popcorn

Different Prices & Varieties

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Graduation Cupcakes

$17.50

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Graduation Cupcakes

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Halloween Cookie Kits (Seasonal)

$25.00 per Kit

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Hot Cocoa Cake Pops (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Add To Cart
(0)

Ice Cream Cake Pop (1 Dozen)

$38.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Lemon Blueberry Cake

$45.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Lemon Blueberry Tray Cake

$20.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Maple Pecan Pastry

$2.99 each

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Mexican Christmas Shortbread Cookies (2 Dozen)

$15.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Mickey Mouse Cupcakes

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Milk Chocolate Heart Cake Pops (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Minnie Mouse Cupcakes

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Molasses Cookies

$.95ea or $9.50 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Mummy Cake Pops (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Orange Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies (Seasonal)

$1.25ea or $12.50 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Paris Cake Pops (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Peanut Butter Cookies

$.95ea or $9.50 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Pineapple Sugar Cookies

$18.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Pink Flamingo Cake

$35.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Powdered Sugar Brownies

$1.25ea or $12.00 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Raisin Oatmeal Cookies

$.95ea or $9.50 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Reese's Cup Tray Cake

$20.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Roasted Pecan Mix for Sugared Pecans

Different Prices & Varieties

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Santa Cookie Kits (Seasonal)

$25.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Signature Chocolate Raspberry Cupcakes (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Signature German Chocolate Cupcakes

$35.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Smores Cookies

$1.25ea or $12.50 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Snicker Doodle Cookies

$.95ea or $9.50 dozen

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Snickerdoodle Cake Pops (1 Dozen)

$25.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Snow Flake Sugar Cookies (1 Dozen Seasonal)

$18.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Spooky Eyeball Pops (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Strawberries -N- Cream Cake Pops (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Sunflower Cupcakes

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Thumbprint Cookies (1 Dozen)

$7.50

In stock

Select Options
(0)

Thumbprint Cookies Green (1 Dozen)

$7.50

In stock

Select Options
(0)

Thumbprint Cookies Orange Purple (1 Dozen)

$7.50

In stock

Select Options
(0)

Thumbprint Cookies Teal (1 Dozen)

$7.50

In stock

Select Options
(0)

Thumbprint Cookies Teal Purple (1 Dozen)

$7.50

In stock

Select Options
(0)

TikTok Drip Cake

$35.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Turnovers

$2.99ea

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Twinkle Twinkle Little Star Cake Pops (1 Dozen)

$35.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Unicorn Cupcakes (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Valentine Heart Cupcakes

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Valentine Thumbprints (1 Dozen)

$7.50

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

Variety Mixes

Different Prices & Varieties

Call to Order 765-855-3344
(0)

Vintage Cherry Chip Cake

$45.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

White Chocolate Heart Cake Pop (1 Dozen)

$30.00

Pickup 3-4 business days-

Select Options
(0)

White Chocolate Peppermint Crunch Cookies (1 Dozen Seasonal)

$9.00

Call to Order 765-855-3344

Cinnamon Spice Bakery

Quality Baked Goods since 2005

Located in Historic Centerville Indiana

Copyright Cinnamon Spice Bakery. All Rights Reserved.

TOP